- Book Review – Hickory Dickory Dock by Agatha Christie

Synopsis: Detective Hercule Poirot senses that his secretary, Miss Lemon, is not attentive while typing his dictation as she used to be. Upon inquiring, she says she is worried about her sister, Mrs. Hubbard. She tells Mayur that inside Mrs. Hubbard’s students’ hostel, certain items are missing regularly. The items are not so valuable but causing annoyance to the students and everyone else. Miss Lemon asks Poirot to investigate the matter and relieve her sister.
Poirot decides to investigate and he joins the police inspector, Sharpe. The inspector interviews the students and discusses the details with Poirot.
During their investigation, one of the female students, Miss Celia Austin, is found dead in her room. They find that she consumed coffee which was mixed with morphine, a poison. Everyone thinks Celia committed suicide, but Poirot thinks otherwise.
He correctly guesses that one of the students, Mrs. Valerie Hubhouse, stole the diamond ring that belongs to Miss Patricia Lane.
While he continues to investigate with Sharpe, he finds that the hostel owner, Mrs. Nicholetis, is found dead on one of the streets. Also, they both are bewildered when they found Miss Patricia Lane is also found dead in her room.
After chasing down the clues and discussing the details with Inspector Sharpe, he finds that the mystery is deeper than he has initially thought. They find it is a handiwork of smugglers who are taking undue advantage of innocent students.
Characters
– Hercule Poirot
– Miss Lemon
– Mrs. Hubbard’s
– Mrs. Nicholetis
The Students at the Hostel
– Mr. Chandra Lal
– Mr. Leonardo Bateson
– Mr. Gopal Ram
– Genevieve
– Mrs. Patricia Lane
– Mrs. Sally Finch
– Mrs. Elizabeth Jhonston
– Mrs. Valerie Hubhouse
– Mr. Colin McNabb
– Mr. Nigel Chapman
– Mr. Akibombo
– Miss Celia Austin
– Mr. Achmed Ali
– Geronimo (cook)
– Marie (cook)
– Inspector Sharpe
*Who Killed Whom?
One of the hostel residents, Mr. Nigel Chapman, kills Celia Austin. Celia is responsible for the missing items in the hostel. But she acts so as per the directions of Valerie Hubhouse. Valerie is the accomplice of Nigel Chapman.
Nigel also kills Mrs. Nicholetis, the hostel owner, because she knew the smuggling racket run by Nigel and Valerie.
Nigel also kills Miss Patricia Lane, who knew the person who took the morphine from her drawer.
*Why?
Nigel kills Celia because she knew Nigel has a fake passport. She knew he was the one who cut the rucksack into pieces. Nigel had to silence her because Celia had told everyone she would reveal who was responsible for the other missing items.
*How?
Nigel mixes morphine into coffee meant for Celia to drink after dinner. He kills Mrs. Nicholetis once again by mixing poison in her drinks at a local bar. He hits Patricia Lane with a hard paperweight that is wrapped in a cloth. He hits the back of her head with it. He places a few strands of hair into Pat’s fingers to misguide the investigators. This red hair belongs to Leonardo Bateson, another student in the hostel.
*Where?
Celia is killed in her room. She consumes her after-dinner coffee that is mixed with morphine.
Mrs. Nicholetis is killed on a street when she consumes a poison mixed drink in a local bar.
Patricia Lane is killed in her hostel room.
*When?
Celia is killed first in the story after she tells others that she would reveal more details about the person who stole the rest of the missing items.
Mrs. Nicholetis is killed next when the police make progress in the case and the killer, Nigel, realizes she might reveal the smuggling racket to them.
Patricia Lane is killed last when she tells Nigel that she replaced the morphine bottle contents with Soda bicarbonate. And someone took it from her room. Nigel thinks that Pat might reveal to the police that Nigel had morphine in his drawer.
*How is this discovered?
– Poirot thinks that Valerie Hubhouse is the one who put the diamond ring in her soup bowl. He thinks it can not be a chef. He thinks that Valerie replaced the diamond with a fake one. And she pawned it soon after stealing it. The diamond ring belonged to Patricia Lane.
– Poirot thinks that the rucksacks were sold in a nearby shop for cheaper prices. He finds that these rucksacks were used to smuggle the goods—narcotics and diamonds—by having hidden pockets at their bottoms. He then concludes that there is a smuggling racket involved including the students who went abroad and returned home.
–Poirot meets Nigel’s family lawyer. The lawyer says Nigel’s father knew Nigel killed his mother. He left a letter before he dies saying Nigel’s confession letter of the crime should be revealed to the police if Nigel commits the second crime. This makes Poirot suspicious about Nigel.
– When Nigel is with Inspector Sharpe at the police station, he received a call from a lady. Nigel speaks and tells Sharpe that the caller was Patricia Lane and she wants to reveal to him who took the morphine bottle from her room. Upon investigation, Poirot concludes that Nigel actually receives a call from Valerie Hubhouse and not from Patricia, who was already dead. Poirot says Nigel and Valerie tried to create a perfect alibi for themselves.
– Finally, the investigators talk to Valerie. She confesses the crime and says Nigel should be hanged.
*What sort of person the murderer was
Nigel Chapman had a bad upbringing. He poisoned his mother and his father sent him out of his home. He told Nigel to stand on his own and decided not to give any money that he had earned. Nigel was an abandoned child and had harbored an animosity with his bitter upbringing.
– Valerie was greedy and it was evident when she stole Patricia’s diamond ring. She was part of the smuggling racket along with her mother, Mrs. Nicholetis.
*What sort of person was the victim?
All the victims—Celia, Patricia, and Mrs. Nicholetis—were naive. Celia loved her boyfriend. She listened to whatever Valerie told her to steal to attract her boyfriend.
Patricia believes in Nigel and reveals everything she knew about morphine. Her innocence took her life in the end.
Mrs. Nicholetis was short-tempered and agreed to meet Nigel at a bar. She never anticipated Nigel would poison her.
*What wring turn, if any, did the investigators take?
Inspector Sharpe believes that Celia committed suicide. They once think that it is Len Bateson, who jumped through Celia’s balcony from his and poisoned her. But Poirot decides to further investigate and finds the real culprit.
*Who, apart from murderers had anything to hide?
The African student, Mr. Akibombo, often makes suspicious statements. He tells the investigators that he had stomach upset after consuming a powder from Patricia’s drawer.
Colin McNabb also hides his real interest in Celia Austin.
*Summary
The story is a character-oriented mystery with a mind soothing and entertaining setting. The manners of students throughout the story keep the reader interested until the ending. Inspector Sharpe conducts the perfect interviews but is Poirot who makes intelligent guesses and presents a solution. This story is another entertaining mystery from Queen of Crime!
*********
You can check out my Mystery and Romance Books
HERE!
My Social Media Accounts are:
https://www.instagram.com/author_vijay_kerji
https://www.facebook.com/vkkerji
So, please stay tuned for my next post!


